Just last year, McFarlane unleashed the new Collector Edition figures onto the market with a hefty $10 price jump over the regular DC Multiverse releases. I was all ready to make my first foray into these pricier figures to see if they seem worth it when McFarlane goes and drops an online store exclusive Infinite Crisis wave for $40 a pop, and I was like holy heck, what are they smoking over there? I mean, I’ll admit that I’m the king of dropping too much money on toys, and even I am not tempted by these kinds of figures at that price. Were they hoping to make these Collector Edition releases seem cheap by comparison? I honestly don’t know, but I’m really interested to see what the collector backlash is going to be like. But for now, let’s get back to the Collector Editions… These seem to be based on more classic or essential versions of characters in the DC Multiverse for an added premium. I was skeptical about how this whole thing was was going to turn out, but decided to give it a try with the first character that really tempted me… Alan Scott! Growing up on Hal Jordan, I can still remember when my uncle blew my little mind by telling me there was another Green Lantern before him and giving me some of his ratty old comics and I devoured the hell out of them. In retrospect, that was probably one of my first realizations that a whole DC Universe had existed for decades before I discovered it. What can I say? I was still really young and dumb and relatively new to reading comics that weren’t Spider-Man or The Fantastic Four.

The packaging is similar to the regular DC Multiverse releases, what with the black box and blue insert behind the tray. “McFarlane Collector Edition” is printed in silver foil lettering up the left side of the front panel and the collector card is now displayed on the tray in its own display stand. On first inspection, that card display is the only thing that really seems to call out that this release is anything special that should make it pricier, and I’ll talk about at the end.

Out of the box, is there anything that really sets this figure apart from the regular releases? Nope. You get the same basic body type and articulation that we’ve been seeing all along. Now, that’s not to say this isn’t a very nice figure, because it certainly is! Apart from the boots, belt, and cape, the figure uses a generic body, but you do get his ring sculpted on his right hand. The colors are beautiful with a deep red for the top and boots, a hunter green used for the pants, and some gold paint for the trim on the boots, belt buckle, and cape clasps. The lantern emblem on his chest is just printed on, but it’s nice and sharp. Factor in the purple and lighter green on the cape, and you have a dazzling deco straight from the comic panels of the Golden Age.

The portrait is very solid, giving Scott some well defined facial features and a rather determined expression. I love the way the high collar on the cape frames his face with one corner licking over a bit more than the other. The mask is sculpted with lots of depth, and the hair is separate from the head giving him a clean hairline. There’s a bit of overspray of the mask’s purple paint onto my figure’s left eye, which is ironically a bigger paint gaff than I’ve had on any of the regular releases. It’s not terribly noticeable unless I punch in close, but still pretty unwelcome for a higher priced Collector figure.

Alan comes with two accessories: His lantern and a power effect part. The lantern can be held in his left hand, while the effect part fits over his right fist. There are no additional hands included, which seems a bit weak for a pricier collector figure. With that having been said, the accessories are quite nice and are cast in a bright neon green semi-translucent plastic.

And then you have the collector card with the stand and as I said earlier, this is the only thing about this whole package that feels really different than a regular Multiverse release. Was anyone asking for this sort of thing? I certainly wasn’t. My cards go into sleeves in a binder and get forgotten about. And quite frankly I’m betting that a lot of these cards just get thrown away with the packaging by figure collectors who just don’t care about them. The cards are cool bonuses, but putting them on a stand takes up about as much shelf real estate as another figure, and like a lot of collectors, I can’t spare that room. Now, I will say that I think Alan Scott is one of the nicer DC Multiverse figures I’ve picked up last year, but there is simply nothing about the figure itself, be it additional paint apps or sculpting, that would justify being sold at a premium. And since I tend to pick up a lot of my regular Multiverse figures on sale, I’m not willing to put up $30 a pop for these unless it’s a figure that I really can’t live without. My biggest concern is that Todd will be using these premium editions for the classic and iconic versions of legacy characters that a lot of collectors have been asking for from this line, when they really should be done as regular releases. I have no doubt you’ll see a few of these Collector Editions land on FFZ in the future, but they will probably be few and far between. And you sure as hell won’t be seeing any figures from that $40 each wave until they hit deep discount bundles on Todd’s site.